well maybe cos carter's ageing lol.
nah i think the ea people look at their performance during the season and judge their dunk ratings by reviewing what they did during games(obviously. i dont know why im saying all these)
ok so maybe they felt that 2004/05 wasnt carter's most fancy year of jams compared to before, and richardson has been throwing it down more than before(baron davis wit all the attention and then the oop to jason for the 360-through-the-leg-windmill dunk or whatever).
but hey wait a minute, didnt carter have kidd? yes carter had much more open looks than before, but not alot of windmill and 360s this season. maybe richardson has more? i dont know,
in my opinion, i think carter's dunking ability peaked and since he got injured, you can see alot of difference in his game in terms of athletism.
richardson i feel that he still got so much stuff up his sleeve cos he aint bothered by injuries, yet.
but yes vince is definitely a better OVERALL player than jrich. the dunk ratings are arguable, but i think if like carter is behind jrich with like 1 or 2 ratings, should be fine