Honestly i think this is closer then most of you think.
If any of you are old enough to remember the 2001 season when vince scored 50 points 3 times that season and lead his team to EC semifinals. Dueling AI and was 2 points away from going to the finals. Vince had the most votes in the All star game, and 2nd to only MJ for most votes all time. He was up there with the best (kobe and iverson)
T Mac in the 03 season put up 60+ points with Orlando and dominated. He was up there with Kobe as the best in the league, yet he couldnt win.
In the end im picking Vince because he proved he could win in his prime, even with little to no support. Tmac was in a similar situation in Orlando, with possibly a worse team, and finished in last i want to say?