[OskarA1991]

Whose going to be the greatest QB out of the players in the poll above?

Vince Young?
Jay Cutler?
Matt Leinart?
Alex Smith?

IMO, it's going to be Vince Young. I really believe he will develope into a great passing QB. Add that to his running game and he is going to be unstoppable.

Jay Cutler comes second here.

[deonlepharaoh]

im from texas so ima pick vince young. i think leinart will be great too if he gets the heck outta phoenix.

[GoRaps420]

vince young.
he is the future face for the NFL jus like vick was.
hes got the whole package, give him some years and hes gonna be one hell of a player.

[Milan]

Alex Smith and Matt Leinart are terrible. Alex smith even moreso. I like Jay Cutler, he's less mobile than Young but his passing game is 5x better. Both are mobile but one has a good arm.

I'd take Good Mobility + Good passing over Great Mobility + Below Average-Bad passing.

[stiza_007]

ive always though jay culter, then leinhart with all the talent around him
as for young his defianlty gonna get better, hill be a star

[HaRdKoRexRoCkEr]

yeah ima say vince young too. hes the most mobile of those quarterbacks, and he had a pretty good throwing arm to compliment it.

[Fresh27]

both vince young and jay cutler played really well today. its hard to pik between them because jay cutler has a great arm and is relatively mobile while vine young is a freak when he runs and also has a decent arm. i would probably go with vince young as the better player because i believe cutler has better supporting players which make him look a lot better while vince young has some average receivers.

as for alex smith he has been very disapointing since he's been in the nfl and i think 49ers should really look into someone else. matt leinart wasnt too bad but he being on IR will affect his development. i believe leinart stil has plenty more chances to prove himself and will come through.

[ut_jazz]

Alex is in a terrible situation in San Fran, you see how losing Turner affected the offense

Just look at what Frank Gore has done, he hasn't had a 100 yard game yet!

3 Offensive Coordinators in 3 seasons! Who goes through that!?!?!?

Alex might have to move on from san fran and be a backup on a good team with a offensive line than when he get's his chance we will see the true Alex Smith

that's the thing, you want to talk about how great QB's are, it's also a question of how good the team they are on. Leinart lucked out and landed on a team with a great offense, as did Jay Cutler. Vince Young hasn't been so good but to my surprise his team is winning

I'd like to think Jay Cutler would end up the best, just because I'm a big broncos fan

[nbaallstar]

Vince Young needs receivers who can actually catch the ball. He needs the targets that Leinart has in order to be the best QB out of the group.

[Crippa]

Best Quarterback in History: Brett Favre
Best Quarterback currently: Peyton Manning
Best Quarterback this season: Tom Brady